Click here to Skip to main content
65,938 articles
CodeProject is changing. Read more.
Articles / database / SQL-Server

EXCEPT vs NOT IN in SQL Server

4.39/5 (12 votes)
10 Jul 2013CPOL 151.2K  
Except vs Not In in SQL Server

Introduction

"EXCEPT" operator was introduced in SQL SERVER 2005. This operator used to achieve Distinct and Not In queries. EXCEPT operator returns all distinct rows from left hand side table which does not exist in right hand side table.

On the other hand, "NOT IN" will return all rows from left hand side table which are not present in right hand side table but it will not remove duplicate rows from the result.

Example of EXCEPT vs NOT IN in SQL SERVER:

SQL
create table #tblsample (ProductId tinyint)
create table #tblsample2 (ProductId tinyint)

--insert values to tbl 1
insert into #tblsample values (1)
insert into #tblsample values (2)
insert into #tblsample values (3)
insert into #tblsample values (4)

--insert values to tbl 2
insert into #tblsample2 values (1)

--SELECT
select * from #tblsample
select * from #tblsample2

--USE EXCEPT
select * from #tblsample
except
select * from #tblsample2

--USE NOT IN
select * from #tblsample
where productid NOT IN(
select * from #tblsample2)

Image 1

SQL
-- INSERT DUBLICATE VALUE
insert into #tblsample values (1)
insert into #tblsample values (2)

--SELECT
select * from #tblsample
--USE EXCEPT
PRINT 'EXCEPT RETURNS DISTINCT VALUES'
select * from #tblsample except select * from #tblsample2
--USE NOT IN
PRINT 'NOT IN RETURNS DUPLICATE VALUES IF ANY'
select * from #tblsample where productid NOT IN(select * from #tblsample2)

--USE DISTINCT + NOT IN = EXCEPT

select * from #tblsample
except
select productid from #tblsample2

Image 2

SQL
--DROP TABLE
DROP TABLE #tblsample
DROP TABLE #tblsample2

License

This article, along with any associated source code and files, is licensed under The Code Project Open License (CPOL)